Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jacquesm 3998 days ago
The bird strike issue seems to me to be vastly exaggerated, windmills are positioned as bird butchering machines with vast numbers of corpses lining their circumference.

In practice it rarely happens, I have windmills (large ones and smaller ones in significant numbers) within spitting distance from my house which also sits in the middle of one of the largest bird breeding grounds in the country. I have spent quite a bit of time at the base of the machines to look for evidence of birdstrikes but I haven't found more bird remains near the windmills than near other man made structures.

Of course I'm only one guy which happens to like rewewable energy technology so don't take my word for this.

There are some studies about this:

http://www.livescience.com/41644-wind-energy-threat-to-birds...

If anything my attempt at evidence collection indicates that the larger machines (which have a much larger swept area than the smaller ones) fare better in this respect because the rotors turn much more slowly, but the tips are still moving at very high speed (200 KM/h) and that's where the danger lies. Smaller machines rotate much faster and the whole disc area is a bad place for a bird to be.

Even so, anything we make (buildings, highways, windmills) affects wildlife and birds are killed by all of the above with the primary killer being the highways and the secondary one the buildings. Windmills do kill birds but they're a distant third.

2 comments

I remember reading that Dutch windmills kill 30K birds per year. Dutch cats kill 30 million birds.
With evolution, if this really was a problem, it would not be one in a few generations :)