[ericd]

Hey Thomas, big fan of your comments generally, but you're mischaracterizing what we did. We never issued another server request to them again after the C&D, let alone changed IP addresses to evade a ban afterwards. This is uncontested, and we weren't included in the CFAA claims. We were fighting for the right to summarize listings and link to them, not for the right to access their servers when they don't want us to, nor to include the full text of the postings on our site.

[tptacek]

Sorry, I was working from the link Techdirt provided to back up the "tortured" application of CFAA. I really wasn't trying to characterize exactly what your team was doing. But I was also imprecise and I sometimes forget that the principals of these stories are on HN, too. I apologize.

[ericd]

No problem, it's hard to know what's going on when every writeup of a story gets at least 30% of the details wrong :-)