Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by _jomo 4009 days ago
I'm using Cyanogenmod and I wanted to try TextSecure. There is a version for SMS pre-installed, but I'm not a fan of paying money for 128 bytes of data.

I don't have any Google Services installed.

So I tried finding it on F-Droid, but it wasn't there. I found out there has been a lot of discussion about this. [0][1]

I decided to compile it on my own. That requires to use use Google Libraries, oh well. I managed to get that done and was disappointed when I tried to use it. It also requires to have Google Services installed on your phone for push notifications. I don't have that.

I tried finding a solution, and other people complained about this and there was the idea to use websockets instead of google push notifications [3]. Someone forked TextSecure and started working on it [4].

Unfortunately that fork isn't stable yet, and it doesn't communicate with 'producion' users of TextSecure [5].

This is where I gave up. It shouldn't be so hard to install a free app on a free system.

Also, the websocket fork is somewhat dead [6].

0: https://f-droid.org/posts/security-notice-textsecure/

1: https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure/issues/127

3: https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure/issues/1000

4: https://github.com/JavaJens/TextSecure

5: https://github.com/JavaJens/TextSecure/issues/10

6: https://github.com/JavaJens/TextSecure/issues/15

2 comments

I had the same experience. I am using CyanogenMod as well and as much as I dislike Google I did install the Play services. I can't even remember why but I think I needed it to use the google voice app.

Anyway, google play apparently tried to auto-update and bricked itself; now it just says "no connection" when I launch the play store.

Last week I tried to install TestSecure but it would not run. It just gave an error message about needing to update play services.

I ended up installing the Telegram app in F-Droid.

I've had Play Services brick itself a few times, but uninstalling all updates tends to fix it.
After all that effort, do you regret not just buying it?
What are you saying the comment parent should have bought? TextSecure is free-libre-open-source software, it isn't sold anywhere. It depends on the Google Play Services, and cannot be run effectively if the framework is not installed on the device.
> There is a version for SMS pre-installed, but I'm not a fan of paying money for 128 bytes of data.

I think I misread this as saying there was a paid-for version available for install, but I have no idea how I got that, since it's clear that it's the SMS charge he doesn't want to pay for.