[hayd]

Then someone else rebases over that commit, there's a conflict and lo! the tests fail. Why? typo. It's fixed in the subsequent commit (which you can't see). Lovely.

There's something to be said for having every commit pass tests/work (or if it doesn't saying explicitly in the commit message), if anyone is ever going to step over this commit.

[damm]

That's a hard one; trying to make a single commit in a pull request helps me but sometimes even then a pull request gets ignored and they want me to rebase it.

The problem is they ask /me/ to rebase it; I think they should take a little ownership in the potential rewriting of history.

[qu4z-2]

There's no potential rewriting of history before they merge your pull request, only a series of unaccepted draft commits. :)