[cactusface]

Why do you need to unconditionally download a binary blob? Can't you just download it when "Enable "Ok Google" to start a voice search" is turned on? And also, it's not really open source anymore even though you delay downloading the non-open parts until runtime.

[mgiuca]

We probably could delay it until the setting is enabled. I wasn't on the team when that decision was made, but I would imagine it's because a) latency (we want the feature to be enabled right away when you turn it on), and b) just the way it happened and nobody really thought much about it at the time.

The fact is that an end user should not care if software downloads a "binary blob" without running it. This is functionally equivalent to downloading anything from the Internet, a JPG file for example. Chromium downloads a bunch of things on startup, and nobody seems to mind. Just because hotword.nexe happens to be an executable blob doesn't really make a difference.

[uptown]

"The fact is that an end user should not care if software downloads a "binary blob" without running it."

Is that the official position of Google? Reminiscent of when Thomas Hesse from Sony stated: "Most people, I think, don't even know what a rootkit is, so why should they care about it?"

[riddly]

Functionally equivalent to a .jpg how? You mean by the fact that the .jpg is an executable set of instructions telling the system to eavesdrop on me?

Great point. Sure, I get it. By that logic, sending me a mail bomb (and of course, not activating it, because I mean who would do such a thing after painstakingly creating it?) is the same as sending me flowers.

[cactusface]

So a picture isn't a picture until you look at it?

Whether or not people should care, some people do care. If Debian has to edit what you distribute to remove proprietary parts of it, you're probably not distributing something that is open source (which means 100% open source).