[Someone1234]

Ouch, that's certainly a step on the wrong direction. I guess they get points for consistency, but they're being consistently bad.

[mst]

If they've found that users almost always say yes to it, that might be the correct choice for being consistently usable even if you (and I) dislike that choice.

[JadeNB]

Enabled-by-default is a defensible choice (even if we don't like it), but it sounds like this is un-disableable, which I think is not defensible.