Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sbuk 4029 days ago
What is "proper" Linux?
2 comments
TickleSteve 4029 days ago
He's probably one of those guys that thinks OSX is a version of Linux... or BSD...

(hint its Mach with a BSD userland).

link
mauricemir 4029 days ago
using both you wouldn't think that Linux works better for one
link
josteink 4029 days ago
In retrospect I'll have to say it's bad wording on my part.

I was referring to Linux as a proper, unrestricted Unix-environment.

link
stephenr 4029 days ago
> I was referring to Linux as a proper, unrestricted Unix-environment

Ironic really, given that OS X is certified UNIX 03, and I don't believe any Linux distribution is.

link
josteink 4029 days ago
Being a licenced Unix is a technicality, mostly involving willingness to pay for a badge.

Being a properly free and unrestricted environment to work with and work in is not. That's something concrete, real and has actual value.

link
teacup50 4029 days ago
> Being a licenced Unix is a technicality, mostly involving willingness to pay for a badge.

It's not, actually. You also have to do a lot of work to conform to the specs.

Linux doesn't. BSDs come very close. Mac OS X is conformant.

link
stephenr 4029 days ago
> Being a properly free and unrestricted environment to work with and work in is not

So why didn't you say that? You said "I was referring to Linux as a proper, unrestricted Unix-environment"

To be pedantic, Linux is the kernel. The environment, is the GNU userland, which is specifically NOT UNIX.

Yes I know it's Unix-like. But when you start your complaint with "it's not proper" try to at least know what you want it to be and what you don't want.

OS X is a "proper UNIX" operating system.

GNU/Linux distributions are free unix-like operating systems.

link