Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mlapeter 6043 days ago
As a real estate agent, I agree with the author's point, especially about the technology. I not only pay hundreds of dollars per year, but technologically they still can't even keep up with basic advancements such as making the mls work in firefox or safari. The problem, as far as I can tell, is not from individual agents trying to protect their racket, but from our regional and national associations and their somewhat opaque partnerships with private businesses.

For example, our national association doesn't even own Realtor.com; they made an apparently permanent agreement with a private company which charges us additional fees for "enhanced" listings.

The other problem is that the MLS's are all controlled regionally, and it's not so much about the technology as it is about the bureaucracy. While the author makes an excellent point, many are currently attempting it but it's not easy. Companies such as Redfin seem to be slowly getting there. As an agent, I'd be the first to support a free, nationwide MLS, but I don't know if it's something that can be solved by technology alone.

1 comments

As someone who worked for an agency supplying a few hundred realtors across 6 different MLSes with web development, I can also testify to the utter technical incompetence of at least one of the major suppliers (who shall remain unnamed) of back-ends for hundreds of MLSes.

I noticed a bug in our CSV import one day and I discovered that they were quoting, but not escaping quotes in any way. Thereby making it possible for any realtor to inject whatever the data they wanted for anyone else's listings either before or after theirs (depending on how the data importers resolved conflicts).

This was a huge security hole affecting probably hundreds of thousands of listings nationwide, and you know what their developer support said to me? They actually sent me a suggested workaround tailored to the particular instance of corrupted data that I had encountered. When I explained to them the ramifications of this to their business they simply ignored me.

Damn I'm glad I got out of that game.

"Hello, this is the front desk."

"Hi, I'm in room 118 and I smell smoke."

"We'll send up some air freshener right away, sir."