Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kasey_junk 4042 days ago
There is no double standard. If patio11 were insinuating that you were a liar, I'd ask him to come right out and say it as well. Skepticism/critical discussion is no cover for rhetorical techniques that amount to trolling.

So 1) stop insinuating he is a liar or 2) make it more concrete. Do you think he is a liar and if so what do you think he is lying about and why? What would it take to make you stop spreading said accusation?

That would be a skeptical argument that could be critically discussed. As it stands, your position is "in the face of lots of evidence that patio11 has produced that indicates he usually writes the truth, I refuse believe him about this specific thing for reasons I will not outline."

I for one believe him because of his long track record of writing things that are verifiable and my own experience as a consumer of consultant products.
1 comments
hnnewguy 4042 days ago
>Do you think he is a liar and if so what do you think he is lying about and why?

I don't understand what you're trying to accomplish. While I don't agree with user=irrigation's comments, I think he's been pretty clear: the claims don't jibe with his experience as a consultant and he's skeptical about the self-promotional aspects. It's hardly ambiguous.

So why are you demanding he come out and call patio11 a liar? That would be an asshole move. Instead he's saying "I don't believe it", and there isn't anything inherently wrong with that. We're all just "some guy" on the internet, who cares?

link
kasey_junk 4042 days ago
He hasn't come out and said I don't believe it (or hadn't as I wrote these comments). He's insinuated that it isn't believable, or that patio11 is lying, but he hasn't just made the claim.

That's what I'm hoping he will say instead of insinuation about a specific person. 1) make a claim. 2) put some counter claims along with it ("I've been doing consulting for X years and never seen a charge rate greater than Y") 3) and if necessary point out what it would take to change the position.

You are right though, I probably shouldn't care, but I really dislike the behavior in this case. It seems like simple trolling trying to hide behind dissent. Which is a disservice to all of us.

link