[petesalty]

But this could just be the vendor (not that I'm defending MS). It could easily be a different price for Google, and another for Yahoo, etc. It doesn't mean MS has any knowledge of this, although they could probably police it if it's affecting their reputation.

[tonyb]

Your exactly right. Search for the same product using google shopping and it shows the higher price.

[jrockway]

Ouch. This is why I usually buy everything from Amazon, instead of some random place that shows up in Google Shopping results.

[oneplusone]

I read a while back that Amazon does something very similar. They give new visitors a larger discount on certain items compared to regular visitors. Of course googling it now only returns http://www.theregister.co.uk/2000/09/06/amazon_makes_regular... so it may be bunk.

[ggrot]

This is pretty old news. Amazon experimented with this briefly, caught alot of flak, and stopped.

I recently had an experience where I thought amazon was doing this - I'd get one price when signed in to prime and another cheaper price when not signed in. I called up amazon and the rep was astonished as she could see the exact same thing. A few minutes of digging and she figured out what happened. Amazon was showing me signed in the item shipped from amazon (candidate for prime) and showing me not signed in the item shipped from someone else. When shipping was added in, Amazon was always showing me the lowest price available. In both cases, I was presented an option to choose a different supplier, but it wasn't very prominent on the page.

[jrockway]

I have gotten my money's worth with Prime, so I am not too concerned. I would be willing to pay slightly more than "suggested retail price" to have something delivered the same day I order it (as happens more and more frequently with Prime orders, even when I pick 2 day shipping), but Amazon does this and their prices are less than any retail store. So I am not going to complain.

(A few weeks ago, I needed a mini-USB cable. I ordered it at about 2am, and it was delivered around noon. All for $4.68...)

[GrandMasterBirt]

Vendors can easily beef up prices and give cash backs because they have to pay a "finders fee" to the engine line google, or anyone in fact. Evil!

[tlb]

I don't read John's post as an accusation of wrongdoing. He's just pointing out something that price-conscious consumers would want to know about.

Bountii is much more powerful than Froogle & Bing because prices aren't just X in one store and Y in another store. Bountii is all about helping price-conscious consumers get the deals most people don't find. Good for them for raising awareness of this new kind of price discrimination.

[mattmaroon]

He asks if its even legal. That's an accusation of wrongdoing in my book.

[jacquesm]

No, it is a question. There is a substantial difference between asking a question and accusing someone of having done something illegal.

[shawndrost]

I'd go further and say that this is a shady blog post from the Bountii crew. If you're going to publicly accuse your competitors of something negative, it's incumbent upon you to be very certain that you're correct. I've emailed them a link to this comment section, and I hope to see this post edited as appropriate.

[Retric]

I don't know how true this is but http://www.butterflyphoto.com/prodinfo.phtml?id=3853&ref... shows gives me 699$. But I can't find it on Bing.

[zyb09]

oh lol the HN police is on the move again!