Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by neuro_imager 4053 days ago
This article is unhelpful, typical of the BMJ.

There are so many different classes and types of psychiatric drugs that even attempting to make sweeping comments like this (one way or the other) are ludicrous.

1 comments

There are so many problems with this article.

> A cohort study of patients older than 65 who were their own control found that all cause mortality was 3.6% higher when patients were taking the newer antidepressants for one year than when they did not take antidepressants.

This is a well known effect where depressed people previously didn't have the energy to follow through with suicides. Some antidepressants increase energy much sooner than they improve mood and so you have a depressed person who now has the energy to follow through with suicide.

Edit: I just realized this article presents both sides of the argument. This just seems like super clickbait for a hot button issue.