Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Phlarp 4058 days ago
>but I can't ever recall a nearly still level hover from a quadcopter.

Seriously? Every one of the DJI products can do this out of the box using just GPS/accel/gyro/barometer. Newer ones can do it even better by adding in a camera pointing at the ground that works like an optical mouse. Some really insane stuff can be done if you throw an active positioning system into the mix: http://www.ted.com/talks/raffaello_d_andrea_the_astounding_a...
1 comments
davismwfl 4058 days ago
Just saw that, thanks for the link. I stand corrected, I hadn't personally seen them stay very still in a hover before, maybe it was operator inexperience.
link
Phlarp 4058 days ago
If the quad has only an accel and gyro sensor onboard then yes, the stability will be based primarily on the skill of the pilot and how well the machine is tuned.

With a GPS and barometer thrown in, position hold should be pretty close to a still hover unless there is significant wind or unresolved problems with the power train

link
TeMPOraL 4058 days ago
I'm surprised that GPS has enough accuracy to do a position hold. Why, then, my cellphone GPS is accurate only to 5-10 meters?
link
Someone 4058 days ago
The copter doesn't need to know where it is, just whether it is moving and if so, how far and in what direction. Because the error in GPS measurements doesn't vary much in small time frames, that can be done more accurately than absolute position measurements. See http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Differential_GPS.
link
Phlarp 4058 days ago
A "good" GPS system (the DJI version is ~$100 by itself I think) should be able to get you down to just a few inches of precision, but yes, the market is flooded with cheap (~$20) units that aren't nearly as useful for position hold (hovering completely still) but can still give you a good lat/long and do well with navigation, distance measuring or acting as a reference sensor for a automatic direction tracking antenna. Cell phones are similarly hit or miss-- some have nicer GPS modules than others, but ultimately the user is unlikely to notice this since smartphone style road navigation only requires 10 meters or so of accuracy and a vague single position can be greatly refined in that context by knowing the road/map layout as well as the direction and speed of travel.
link
davismwfl 4058 days ago
That makes sense. Thanks for sharing more info, I like learning.
link