Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dmichulke 4068 days ago
About "profit by ignoring them":

- Is food profit?

- When I'm hungry -is food profit?

- When my family is hungry and I don't pay taxes in order to buy food today - is it profit?

- What if I don't pay taxes in order to send my kid to a school?

- What if I don't pay taxes in order to send my kid to a good school?

- What if I collect taxes from people who could otherwise send their kids to school?

There are a million possible definitions of profit and I bet that to each of them I can invent a scenario where it's simply unjust.

1 comments

And for each of your scenarios I can invent two in which your actions are just parasitic, in which you freeload on your community. It's easier to make a profit when you don't play by the same rules as everyone else. Also, if you run a startup, you're likely not struggling to feed your kids, so the moral picture you're painting does not apply.