Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by paulojreis 4063 days ago
While technically interesting (assuming they ported iOS frameworks), it's no more than a hack, UI-wise. It prompts developers to consider the UI as an afterthought; just "trust" Microsoft's adaptation of another platform layout, add "minimal changes" and presto: UI work is done.

It's a sad route to follow, if you truly care about your users.

1 comments

Source? I didn't think they had released any example screenshots of "converted" apps yet.
I don't think you need a source to know that either a) they do some automatic "adaptation" of the layout elements; or b) they render it as iOS does. Neither of these scenarios is optimal, nor prone to great UI work.

Anyway, my point concerns more the concept/approach than the exact implementation. "Converting" is proposed as an easy path to have your product on other platform, as opposed to doing all the due work to address differences and specificities.