Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by IkmoIkmo 4075 days ago
Bitcoin is pretty much digital cash. There is no institution that governs the transfer of cash, as in if you pay at a store with cash, or pay a friend cash, or pay a criminal cash, or buy some drugs with cash, there's no 3rd party involved here like say a Paypal or bank transfer.

Bitcoin is like that.

But like bitcoin and cash, institutions are part of the ecosystem. You likely get paid by regulated organisations such as an employer or company, you may store your cash with a third party like Paypal, a bank or a bitcoin wallet service like Coinbase. You may exchange your cash into a different currency, or have a company send your cash somewhere, and institutions are involved just like with bitcoin.

And all these organisations are generally subject to the same, or stricter regulatory oversight. In most states for example, bitcoin companies are considered money transmitters and subject to your regular money transmitter laws. And in some states like New York, actual bitlicenses are being designed to specifically provide bitcoin/cryptocurrency regulations in addition to these laws, not replacing them.

The fact that not everyone uses institutions, or that some illegal institutions exist (just like how some use cash without using banks see [0], or use illegal organisations for their financial services (e.g. Hawala remittance services instead of Western Union, illegal in many countries), is no different from people using bitcoin without involving an institution, or using bitcoin services that don't follow their regulatory obligations. (the minority of popular wallet companies, exchanges etc, btw).

So... no miracle here. It's extremely similar to cash as we know it. Not exactly similar of course.