[pc2g4d]

You seem to be judging the worth of an argument by the "strangeness" of its implications. That's a curious standard.

[voteforchange]

I think we would all agree that persuasiveness is an axis upon which to judge arguments. "Strangeness" is far out there on the persuasive axis.

Maybe so far out there that Richard Dawkins and Neil Degrasse Tyson are arguing in the other room... but its on the axis somewhere.