Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rodly 4086 days ago
I think part of the reason for this is that generally speaking, people who eat poorly know they're eating poorly and would rather have their cake and eat it too. They know soda is bad for them and that apples are good for them. That sitting all day long doesn't expend a lot of energy and running the back hills for a half hour does.

So when someone asks an ill person who eats poorly "How have you been eating?" they know they're about to receive a long story about how they've tried and failed, or that lately they've been "cheating" or that they've been super busy at work and kids and life is hard and they have no time for such things. What's the doctor supposed to say after this? Nothing. Because people are only going to change themselves when they truly want to and not when someone tells them they should.

So instead they look for more efficient routes at attempting care. Drugs are pretty good at this for a while. Got high blood pressure? Here's some beta blockers. You got an aching back? Here's some pain medication for that. They make more money this way, their patients can reliably take the 3 seconds to swallow a pill everyday, and everyone seems to be pretty happy until they have a heart attack or need a wheelchair. It's a good thing that those things come with old age so their poor health condition can be blamed on yet again something other than their continued poor diet and lack of exercise.

It's funny how simple being healthy is. Sleep, diet and exercise.

2 comments

> their patients can reliably take the 3 seconds to swallow a pill everyday

This isn't even close to being true. Compliance is one of the biggest issues in modern medical practice. And people who reliably take the three seconds to swallow a pill every day are much, much healthier than people who don't, no matter what's in the pill.

Meh, your both wrong. When appropriate, doctors do ask about diet, they do recommend changes to diet, it does make a difference, and being healthy is not necessarily simple.
You basically reinforced his point. People know what they're doing wrong, and when they want to change that part of their lifestyle, then they will and any doctor will be more than happy to help them. There's such a thing as a dietitian after all.
Meh, my point is diet is always appropriate. And it is.