[eliben]

We're actually working on a heuristic that can signal yapf to break arguments to one per line, and do the same for data structures (think a dict initialization).

Ultimately, we'd like to have these things configurable via the style settings of yapf, so multiple detailed styles can be selected.

Patches welcome :)

[zo1]

If you'd like my suggestion. I've been quite annoyed with some of the "odd" or "non-consistent" ways for splitting long lines onto multiple lines (either on definitions, or plain calls to functions). Eventually, I did come up with a consistent way to do so. Have a look at below:

    def OtherLongFunctionName(One,
      Two,
      Three
    ):
        print "Does stuff"
    
    def MyFunction(Param1,
      OtherParam,
      FooParam,
      EtcParam
    ):
        if ((Param1 * 1000) > 5000 &&
          OtherParam is not None &&
          len(FooParam) > 50
        ):
            new_instance_dict = {
              "TestingFoo": Param1,
              "NewFoo": OtherParam,
              "LongFooBar": FooParam,
            }
    
        recursive = MyFunction(
          OtherLongFunctionName(
            Param1,
            OtherParam,
            FooParam
          )
        )

It doesn't comply to PEP8 due to the indentation of nested params and stuff on the new lines. PEP8 apparently wants them aligned with the opening/starting bracket. This looks horrible, and just right-aligns all your code into little columns. And doesn't work very well with nested function calls.

[data_scientist]

Please don't make it configurable, because it will mean there is no longer "a" YAPF standard. Also look at Pycharm reformat tool, it would be a shame if both couldn't be used in the same versionned project.