Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by michellegreer1 6073 days ago
The best physicists probably can't surf.

I'd be shocked if a professional surfer could tell me much about physics.

Just because you can, it doesn't mean you necessarily should. I'm a lot more effective as a marketer when I am selling someone else's code versus something I could scrap together.

5 comments

Garrett Lisi is a pretty good surfer/physicist: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antony_Garrett_Lisi
nice find! amazing guy.
this is exactly why stereotypes and generalizations are a disservice to everyone. there are times when statistics are applicable, eg making business decisions based on market research. maybe it is even relevant when deciding what to write about. however, it is complete baloney when it comes to making a judgment about individuals. For that matter, it makes for a stupid, black-and-white, controversial blog post title...which i suppose is the point.
I think most surfers have a more intuitive sense of physics than normal people. We are after all the only ones that actually ride waves - and waves, be they sound or light, are pretty important in physics :)

This doesn't excuse programmers from ignoring your advice. We're a stubborn lot, and we make a living diving into situations where we have no idea what the hell we're doing, figuring it out, and carrying the day that way. We try to apply that to marketing, which is why most of our companies fail - it doesn't work that way in other fields. The ability to learn on the fly is usually more costly than it is with building software.

Being a physicist and being a surfer are not particularly correlated. As it turns out, being a physicist is rare, as is being a surfer, so finding a physicist surfer is unlikely, but that alone doesn't speak to the correlation of those skills.

Having a debilitating disease such as ALS is almost certainly much more strongly negatively correlated with being a physicist than is surfing, yet nobody would be silly enough (given the notable counter example) to say "people with ALS can't be physicists" as a blanket statement.

A large number of astrophysicists (especially the ones with a Astronomy bent) tend to be of the hippy/surfer crowd. Or at least used to be!
Apparently, you've never heard of Garrett Lisi.

But he is definitely not your standard Physicist.