Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sandworm 4108 days ago
Rare is a difficult term to nail down. I was taken aback by the statement that he had only seen two cases over 23 years.

To think of how not-rare it is, think of all the heterosexual child abuse that goes on within families. Child abuse is not considered rare. But how many of those abuses might result in pregnancies? Any doctor who deals regularly with young people, specifically young girls who might be pregnant, sees this regularly if they care to look. The pregnant teenager whose boyfriend "isn't around anymore" is a non-rare situation. Some subset of those are pregnant by their fathers/brothers. The problem is that asking, or performing tests that might identify the true father, may do more harm than good. So doctors don't push the matter. That doesn't mean they do not suspect what's going on.

What do you say to a girl pregnant by her brother? Termination is not a great option, the kid may well be healthy. Reporting the abuse, breaking up the household, isn't going to help either. From the doctor's perspective there isn't much they can do.

1 comments

> What do you say to a girl pregnant by her brother? Termination is not a great option, the kid may well be healthy. Reporting the abuse, breaking up the household, isn't going to help either. From the doctor's perspective there isn't much they can do.

This attitude, while understandable, is very damaging.

You report the abuse. You do so because your professional registration probably tells you to; there might even be mandatory laws requiring you to; and because you know that you do not have access to reports from other agencies (police, school, sexual health clinics, etc) and so you cannot understand the whole picture.

You're right that interventions for abused children are appalling and that looked after children have some pretty lousy outcomes (shorter life, lower quality of life, increased mental illness, increased risk of death by suicide, increased criminal behaviour, etc etc etc)

You advocate handing the matter over to government, even though you know government fails to handle it better than not? That's cruel.