Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by the_mitsuhiko 4117 days ago
> What reasons do you have to you believe this statement? I'm curious.

Did you use it? Gitlab has barely any open source projects let alone developers on it. Say as much as you want, but for many open source projects community is a big deal.

Currently there is absolutely no reason to use Gitlab. Neither does it do things better than Github or Bitbucket in any way, nor does it have a larger community. It's "just" another github clone.

> Really? I'm surprised. I started coding a forum platform and I only amassed 3 stars. On my non-furry personas, I've capped out at about 13.

The second biggest project on gitlab has 36 stars: https://gitlab.com/explore/projects/starred

The 9th largest already has less than the 13 stars you mentioned on your personal project.
1 comments
some_furry 4117 days ago
> Currently there is absolutely no reason to use Gitlab.

http://techcrunch.com/2014/12/05/to-get-off-russias-blacklis...

Since you used the words, "absolutely no reason", here's a counterpoint: as part of an anti-censorship hydra effort.

    All X is Y.
    At least one X is not Y.
    ^-- contradiction
:)
link
the_mitsuhiko 4117 days ago
> Since you used the words, "absolutely no reason", here's a counterpoint: as part of an anti-censorship hydra effort.

I don't see how this is relevant at all? First of all github did not remove that content, it IP blocked it. Secondly what do you think that gitlab would do if they would be hit by this?

Do you think it's better for github to go down for Russia entirely? Imagine that would be your proposal for what gitlab should do. Then it would even stronger enforce that gitlab is not a place to go for an Open Source project.

Why should your project suffer and become unavailable because some other project violated Russian law?

link
some_furry 4117 days ago
You said "absolutely no reason" and I gave you an edge case that invalidates your statement.

Maybe "generally no reason" would be better?

link
the_mitsuhiko 4117 days ago
Nothing in the world is absolute. However so far I have not hear any non nebulous reasons why an Open Source project should be on gitlab.
link
mintplant 4117 days ago
Because GitLab is open source, and the alternatives (GitHub, BitBucket) are not.
link
the_mitsuhiko 4117 days ago
> Because GitLab is open source, and the alternatives (GitHub, BitBucket) are not.

That's not a reason to use the hosted gitlab version, that might be a reason to self host gitlab.

link
some_furry 4117 days ago
> Nothing in the world is absolute.

I'll drink to that :)

> However so far I have not hear any non nebulous reasons why an Open Source project should be on gitlab.

Heh, that's okay. I'm not here to convince anyone of anything.

link