Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dragonwriter 4123 days ago
> Could you elaborate on what you consider to be "bad REST" with regards to using POST in this case?

I'm not saying POST is bad REST, I am acknowledging the claim by some that it is and, without debating whether or not it is, saying that using REPORT or SEARCH, as currently defined, is at least as bad as using POST from a REST point-of-view.

(I actually think that, in terms of using HTTP in a RESTful way, POST is the least-bad choice in terms of existing verbs, though it is not an exceptionally good fit -- its basically a case where POST-works-for-anything-for-which-no-other-method-seems-appropriate logic applies.)

1 comments

Ah, my bad, I misunderstood. Thanks for clarifying!