[jghn]

In my group we actually go old school, sit around at a table with printouts for a lot of things (not the trivial stuff). It gets a lot of raised eyebrows from other groups in the company and I was skeptical when I joined but I've come to really appreciate it.

I've found two things happening:

1) People are often more engaged in the actual review than in other groups I've been in which are doing online reviews. And here I'm talking more about a back and forth and not necessarily "everyone says their one thing". Because of this, I believe our group's thinking of stuff has evolved more rapidly than it otherwise would have. Which leads me to ...

2) It's been better for ramping new members up to speed as it's a great place for them to ask questions, not to mention listen in to the debates happening.

I hadn't done an old style code review like that for at least 10 years, but I have to say that I've enjoyed it.