Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by maratd 4131 days ago
> 70 million people is a lot of people.

So one person isn't a lot of people ... are you saying one person is negligible? That one person's life doesn't matter?

Two can play this game.

1% is 1%. Every life is important, but 1% is still 1%. And 1% is not a lot. Whether it's people, apples, or pencils doesn't matter. It's a ratio.

1 comments

> So one person isn't a lot of people ... are you saying one person is negligible? That one person's life doesn't matter?

Can we make laws, do medical research, etc. that will effectively help 1 person? I don't think so. If I see one person by the side of the road with a flat tire, I'll help that 1 person, but in the context of policy and research, 1 person usually doesn't matter because policy and research can't usually create a meaningful impact.

We can, however, make laws and do medical research that has an impact on 70 million people. I present as evidence for this the fact that life has gotten better (according to a variety of shared values which we could agree upon--fewer suicides, less violence) in the last few decades for people of atypical sexes.

> 1% is 1%. Every life is important, but 1% is still 1%. And 1% is not a lot. Whether it's people, apples, or pencils doesn't matter. It's a ratio.

No, context matters. If you don't think 1% is a lot in any context, maybe let's get you up to a 1% blood alcohol and see how you feel (hint: you won't feel).

>We can, however, make laws and do medical research that has an impact on 70 million people.

Which is nothing this thread of discussion was about.

Nobody said not to study or legally hep those people.

Just that 1% is not enough to describe the total of cases as a "spectrum".

> Which is nothing this thread of discussion was about.

> Nobody said not to study or legally hep those people.

> Just that 1% is not enough to describe the total of cases as a "spectrum".

Assuming that your medical and social policies are at all data-driven, failure to include people in your data is a guaranteed way to ensure that they are not studied or legally helped.