Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by chez17 4140 days ago
It bothers me when people post statistics out of context. If the unemployment rate was 48% and now it's 24% that's an amazingly successful policy to cut unemployment by half. If it was 12% and now it's 24% clearly something is wrong if unemployment doubles. Honest question, what is going through your mind when you post a statistic like that with absolutely context? How, to you, does this prove a point one way or the other?
2 comments

I think the context in this case is the usual, everyday awareness of typical unemployment rates, which politically conscious individuals tend to have.

For instance, at the very least people probably have heard that U.S. unemployment has been anywhere from 9% to 5% in recent years. And we know that things were pretty bad when unemployment was 9%, and surely 24% is a lot worse than 9%.

If you were good at U.S. history, you might recall that our great depression had similar unemployment rates. There's just about no context where that's a good number.

I grew up in parts of East Germany that had 27% for years. Not pretty.
Here's a graph of the change:

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-fvsTRmORSVI/T5qPyXygwNI/AAAAAAAAEU...

It's not hard to find the facts and the context here, so your comment makes no sense whatsoever.