Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by prof_hobart 4152 days ago
That tax idea seems fraught with issues to me.

It talks about the BBC as a comparison, and I'm a great admirer of the BBC, but I'm not sure that's a relevant model for internet as a whole. The Beeb is governed by a specific charter covering what it should and shouldn't do. And whilst there's theoretically no government interference in day to day content, there is an explicit understanding that the government could pull their charter if they don't like what they are up to.

Only giving funding to web content that complies with a government-sanctioned charter doesn't seem a great future to me, and it becomes a worryingly small step from there to outright blocking anything that breaches it.

1 comments

"That tax idea seems fraught with issues to me."

All the more reason to discuss it and explore what those issues might be.

Which is what I've just done.
Indeed.
Are you in support of the proposal? If so, do you have any comment on the concerns I raised?