Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mihok 4153 days ago
Why is this only offered to lawyers and legal professionals? I have had countless scenarios where I just want to look up something regarding the laws surrounding a topic but get lost looking for accurate legal information... This seems like a perfect solution for that use case, no?
3 comments

Watson's good, but it's not that advanced. It's an 'expert system', in that it's a system for experts, not a system that is an expert.

This is a smarter, domain-specific search engine. You still need to be able to ask the right questions and then understand interpret the results it provides.

I still don't disagree that for certain 'low-stakes' issues it could be a useful tool for lay persons, but they'd need to understand the limitations. Perhaps they're worried that giving such access might tarnish the Watson brand -- if a medical doctor has tried Ross and found it wanting then when they roll out 'House' she might dismiss it as junk based on that experience.

No. It's more like StackOverflow. You wouldn't send a non-programmer there for basic questions, it's for people who work in the field looking for specific answers.
One issue is that they'd have to be very careful to ensure they're not seen as providing legal advice.