Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by AnthonyMouse 4174 days ago
In what way is militarization going to defend against the likes of the Sony attack?

The government is not equipped to handle this kind of security. You can't post marines in US data centers to keep out foreign attackers, that's not how it works. Offense isn't a defense; MAD doesn't work when you can't reliably attribute attacks or the attacker doesn't have any meaningful infrastructure to retaliate against.

The best thing the government could do in this context is provide money for public security research and for security audits of popular software. But that has nothing to do with the military or offensive capability, and the government seems intent on going the other way with their renewed attacks on the widespread use of encryption.
1 comments
diminoten 4174 days ago
Private companies shouldn't be going to war against nation states. The US government should be able to defend itself and its citizens from attacks by foreign nations.

Maybe you're right and the answer is to let private companies wage wars against nations, but right now US government agencies have to sit on their hands due to a lack of direction from congress on these issues.

There is no RoE for cyberwar. There really ought to be.

link
AnthonyMouse 4174 days ago
It isn't a war. Nobody dies.

There is nothing for US government agencies to do. When a bank gets robbed because they held their money in a cardboard box instead of a vault, the question is not what the FBI can do to prevent that. The location of the problem is not the government. The location of the problem is the cardboard box.

link
diminoten 4174 days ago
What?

These aren't some random bank robbers, these are entire countries.

What the hell do I pay the US government for, if not to protect me from other nations?

No one even has remotely enough budget to deal with foreign nations attacking them. Not Google, not Microsoft, nobody.

link
AnthonyMouse 4174 days ago
> These aren't some random bank robbers, these are entire countries.

Sony's annual revenue is more than North Korea's GDP. That there can be a legitimate question as to whether the Sony attack was carried out by North Korea or some individual with a grudge probably puts it into the proper context.

> What the hell do I pay the US government for, if not to protect me from other nations?

That's a fair point; maybe we shouldn't pay them as much.

> No one even has remotely enough budget to deal with foreign nations attacking them. Not Google, not Microsoft, nobody.

So budget is the issue then? Maybe you're on to something here -- we can cut the NSA's budget and give the money to Google and Microsoft and other tech companies so they can use it to improve security.

link
diminoten 4174 days ago
I'm glad you think you can spitball solutions to global issues better than folks who do it for a living.

That must feel good, for you.

link
AnthonyMouse 4173 days ago
Right, sorry, I was mistaking this for a democracy. We should definitely just do whatever the man from the government said and not think about it too hard.

But remind me again how the military is going to defend against the likes of the Sony attack?

link