| HN Mirror

From my understanding, the author was complaining about the way default arguments mess up implementations of currying. If default arguments were included in the .length, then all existing currying implementations would carry on working with no modifications, they would just ignore the default values and require that we pass in values explicitly.

Let's say we have these functions:

    function getElem(arr, index=0) { return arr[index]; }
    var curried = curry(getElem);

In a hypothetical world where default arguments are included in the length, we would have to supply them explicitly. That's no big deal though, it's just a potential inconvenience:

    // Hypothetical, "better" semantics
    var arr = ["a", "b", "c"];
    console.log(curried(arr));     // partially-applied function, *not* "a"
    console.log(curried(arr, 0));  // "a"
    console.log(curried(arr, 1));  // "b"

The ES6 semantics is worse because we cannot provide a non-default argument to a curried function:

    // Actual, "worse" semantics
    console.log(curried(arr));     // "a"
    console.log(curried(arr, 0));  // Error: attempts to run `"a"(0)`, but "a" is not a function
    console.log(curried(arr, 1));  // Error: attempts to run `"a"(1)`, but "a" is not a function

The reason this is particularly unfortunate is that one major use-case of currying is to provide default arguments! In other words, by adding default arguments to the language in this way, ES6 is breaking an existing mechanism for default arguments!

I would argue that currying is actually more general than default arguments, so if it's a choice between one or the other, they should have added currying to the language instead of default arguments.

They're not quite comparable, but you can think of currying as supplying default arguments "dynamically" (at the call site), whereas regular default arguments are supplied "statically" (at the definition site). For example:

    // Give "y" a default value for everyone
    var defaultMultiply = function (x, y=2) { return x * y; };

    console.log(defaultMultiply(5, 7));  // 35
    console.log(defaultMultiply(5));     // 10

    // Don't commit to any defaults yet
    var curryMultiply = curry(function(x, y) { return x * y; });

    console.log(curryMultiply(5, 7));  // 35

    // Give "x" a default value, to act like defaultMultiply
    var double = curryMultiply(2);

    console.log(double(5));  // 10

    // Give "x" a different default, which we can't do with defaultMultiply
    var triple = curryMultiply(3);
    console.log(triple(5));  // 15

I've implemented and used currying in JS, PHP and Python, and I found JS the most pleasant, specifically because it didn't have default values.