[natemartin]

If I'm understanding you correctly, how is this different from something like reddit or digg? You can read the discussion on reddit before reading the actual news.

Unless I'm misunderstanding.

[muzrix]

yes u misunderstood it.

on reddit/digg, people submit the actual news link that generated the comments based on that news

my idea is, people submit the comment first on any specific topic that result people produced a 'news' based on that comments

[natemartin]

Perhaps "news" is the wrong term to use then?

In my mind, news if referring to an event that has occurred (even if that event is the stating of someone's opinion)

Maybe "article" is a better term, or even "essay".

Someone chooses a topic, people discuss it, and then someone works that discussion into an essay about that topic.