Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ky3 4186 days ago
mathematical proofs are difficult enough to follow without having to guess the action of the operators involved.

What Heaviside did was the sort of fast-and-loose syntactic manipulation that makes mathematicians queasy and/or indignant [1]. He treats the derivative operator just like it were an ordinary number X. And then he infers that 1/X must mean integration.

Compare to the naive argument for the positive integers 1+2+3+... summing to -1/12 that gets mathbabe's panties in a twist [2].

More details in Ch. 10 of Nahin's book.

[1] http://myreckonings.com/wordpress/2007/12/07/heavisides-oper...

[2] http://mathbabe.org/2014/01/21/if-its-hocus-pocus-then-its-n...