Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by codazzo 4198 days ago
If somebody ever asks me "what does mansplaining mean?" I'm just going to say, "Well you see, it's quite easy. Just read this blog post"

In all seriousness, there was no need for the point in this post to be explained through such exemplary mansplaining.

3 comments

Oh come on. I'm not even sure "mansplaining" is a thing, but even it is, in no way does "mansplaining" == "socratic method".

Also, did you even know Alex Potato is a man†? I know two Alex's, one male, and one female. I've never spoken to a potato.

Or is it automatically "mansplaining" because the topic is about a specific woman being underpaid/overworked, and any helpful suggestions to that specific women (that reframe the situation and empower her to improve things herself) are automatically sexist? I mean, I'm happy to condemn employment conditions that systemically underpay women, but that won't actually help Sam, whereas this advice might.

In conclusion, whilst obviously not everything men write or say that is intended to be supportive of feminism is actually helpful and supportive, it really worries me that if men who are trying to help are shot down for missing the mark, then fewer will try in future, and the only ones left commenting will be the trolls who are looking for such a reaction.

† I mean, we could assume they were because they appear to work in software or the like, and play paintball, but we shouldn't do that because it would be sexist, right‡?

‡ Did I just "mansplain" there too? Ooops.

Mansplaining is a thing, really. But this reads like Socratic dialogue to me. At least I hope it's not a literal transcript of an actual conversation.
I don't see anything on that page that indicates Alex has stated a gender identity, so that's an awfully presumptuous thing to say. Maybe you should stop mansplaining?
We used to call this a Socratic dialogue, but I'll update my vocabulary. Thanks for the notice.
This really isn't an example of mansplaining.