Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lolwutf 4226 days ago
I suspect there is a pro-Uber force on HN that downvotes any anti-Uber sentiment on HN, based on my own past experiences posting anti-Uber commentary. Whether or not that pro-Uber force is controlled by Uber, themselves, is unclear.

One example:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8328493

...notice 2 of 3 replies indicate surprise at how much I was being downvoted.

2 comments

If it helps, my first impression of that post was you highlighting individual actions to smear the governing body.

eg.

>Christianity causes people to murder and steal, because the perpetrator of a murder/theft was Christian.

Any large group will have a number of bad actors, that is not indicative of anything except the large group being large. Even "interfering with the normal course of competitor's business" was an action of one firm, though it's pretty clear Uber allowed such actions to continue.

and finally "price surges" and "price gouging during states of emergencies." are ethically on the fence. People with a capitalistic bent would not find these immoral. Whether you feel our monetary distribution system is fair is another matter... I would argue that if wealth was fairly distributed (operating on my definition of fair here) then that would be a perfectly moral thing.

All this is to say: You were REALLY trying hard to smear Uber. Just like this article is. Which is really weird, because Uber's done enough things to smear themselves. They don't need help.

I'm not pro-Uber; these services are irrelevant where I live. I just hate gossipy toxic threads, so I flag.
Sometimes life is messy. Can't sweep everything under the rug.

If nothing else, this is a good reminder to never trust the press. Too bad the press is the only tool we have to keep an eye on the other people you should never trust (politicians, ceos, etc). Instead, you should trust the anonymous internet commenters ! Oh, shit...what just happened?

I like to browse HN via https://news.ycombinator.com/newcomments

So, I just saw the comment and told why it may have "disappeared." I never read the OP, and don't intend to waste my time reading it. Apparently, many people don't like that I don't care about Uber. At all. Ironically, that just removed my flagging ability.

But the article we are talking about are about something which is actually damaging and appalling. As for the truth or source, well, that is sth we always have to go with the journalist's integrity and then rely on analysis and discussion which we contribute to.