Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pinpoll 4264 days ago
Being a privat pilot myself, I was fascinated by the story of AF Flight 447 from both a human and technical point of view, since many times, a combination of these two factors would eventually lead to an unpleasant situation.

This documentary about AF Flight 447 is the best I found so far: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TsgyBqlFixo

...including the last words of the pilots.

2 comments

After watching this this it baffles me that:

There is no (central) display indicating the current position of both control sticks.

There is no redundant system allowing the pilots to see their speed, even if the method used is inaccurate it would still be better than nothing (GPS, heated pitot tubes, ...) Same for the altimeter.

Flight recorders aren't designed to float and broadcast their position, or at least release a small beacon that would give rescue teams a general idea about where to search.

>>Flight recorders aren't designed to float and broadcast their position, or at least release a small beacon that would give rescue teams a general idea about where to search.

They are not designed to float, because there is no guarantee that the flight recorder will separate from the rest of the wreckage, but most importantly because accidents at cruise altitude are incredibly rare, it's the safest time of the flight - and you are very unlikely to be over the ocean in any other mode of flight. Even with airports close to the sea, a crash few km from the shore would not be difficult to locate.

And flight recorders have auxiliary batteries and actually broadcast their location for a month after the crash - the problem here was that no one had an idea where the plane crashed, something that's very,very improbable in its own right.

I also recommend documentary shown on National Geographic about this flight. I believe it's one of the Air Crash Investigation series.