[DanBC]

> Edit: As to pointing out flaws in an experement. Again there is no progress as removing evidence in support of a theory does not get you any where you need new evidence in support of a different theory for there to be progress.

Are you saying that failure to replicate an experiment has no impact on the original experiment?

Are you getting this from people like http://wjh.harvard.edu/~jmitchel/writing/failed_science.htm ?

[Retric]

Failure to replicate an experement is new evidence in support of a different theory.