[tspiteri]

I find that quite a conceited view of mass tourism, borne of the fact that the author has a "fantasy of being a real individual, of living somehow outside and above it all." Sometimes it is fun to be a tourist at a place where there are other tourists around. And I hate that he says tourists are "economically significant but existentially loathsome". If it weren't for tourists, many tourist attractions would be neglected because firstly there would be no point in maintaining them, and secondly, there would be no money to maintain them.

[klodolph]

> If it weren't for tourists, many tourist attractions would be neglected because firstly there would be no point in maintaining them, and secondly, there would be no money to maintain them.

Or, in other words, they are economically significant.

[tspiteri]

The whole quote I am contesting is "economically significant but existentially loathsome", and my point is that not only are tourists not existentially loathsome, but they give purpose to the maintenance of attractions.

[cturner]

Near Reykjavik there's a site called something like the Golden Falls. It's a pretty waterfall. I joined a busload of retirees and other holiday-makers on a tour of sites. We stopped there, went for a walk along the concrete, saw the waterfall, photos, spent five minutes in the tourist shop, and then got back in the bus.

I considered the golden waterfalls as they would have been to hikers for centuries: a visual oasis that people stumble upon or towards after hiking for days. That would have been glorious. But - apart from these thoughts - it was otherwise meaningless.

You can't appreciate such a thing from the comfort of a bus journey and concrete walkways. The presence of the trappings of tourism would significantly deplete the value of the thing if you had hiked to it like the ancients had. Unless you were thirsty. Or injured.

[JoeAltmaier]

And food tastes much, much better if you work hard and abstain for hours beforehand. But few of us get to do that. Maybe that's why we demand ever-more-vivid food experiences as we age? Bored of chicken soup and good bread, we want McCheese with curly fries or ultra-hot-sauce wings.

[tptacek]

Whoah, McDonalds near Reykjavik has McCheese and curly fries? What's McCheese like? Does it go on the fries?

Sorry. Some people gape at the majesty of a waterfall. Some people find... other... wellsprings for inspiration.

[glurgh]

There should be guides like that for the world's great sights.

http://goo.gl/maps/n9dGc

Reward: Chicken Maharaja Mac

[JoeAltmaier]

:) But what's this about Reykjavik? How on earth could you know that?

[coldtea]

You'd be surprised. Ask a local that you don't deal with economically as a tourist for the real answer.