Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by graycat 4285 days ago
> rival the usability

Not really their utility! Search by keywords/phrases sorted by popularity and date do not fully replace a good directory which, in contrast, can be a list curated by human experts in ways that keywords/phrases cannot more then just begin to characterize.

Rough, old proof of this point: Why the Yellow Pages, with their categories and ads, were so much more useful than just the white pages. E.g., the ads gave a lot of details beyond just the keywords used in the alphabetical lookup. So, do the alphabetical lookup and then look at the ads for more details. The larger ads in effect were a curation.

And there are other examples of directories.

Am I the only one who thinks this way?