[joshdance]

Your post could be called "Why the company culture where I experienced scrum should die in a fire"

It is all about the implementation. Just today I had a manager, remind the developers who were talking too much that the meeting needed to be over in 15 mins. Horrible long meetings is a culture thing.

Blaming someone for something because they left early is a culture thing.

Managers sitting everyone standing is a culture thing.

Scrum is a tool. You can use it badly, and horrible cultures will use it badly.

[davidgerard]

When we went Scrum, I can say that my favourite bit was the free E-meter at every desk. The Kool-Aid tasted a bit funny, though.

Your logical fallacy is: No True Scotsman. http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/No_True_Scotsman