Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by untog 4300 days ago
"Banking is already well established in Scotland and in the same way that New York’s banking infrastructure has slowly given rise to a growing clutch of tech companies"

Two thoughts: many Scottish banks have indicated that they will relocate in the event of independence:

http://money.cnn.com/2014/09/11/news/economy/scotland-indepe...

and I'm not so sure that the NYC tech scene has sprung up as a result of its banking industry. In many ways it has held it back, by taking a lot of tech talent.

"There’s a real opportunity for growth in an Independent Scotland as a direct result of significant foreign investment (see the Irish tiger of the 80s and 90s)."

Given the current state of Ireland, I really, really, really don't think you want to use the Irish tiger as a possibility for a future Scotland.

2 comments

Two thoughts: many Scottish banks have indicated that they will relocate in the event of independence:

Relocating a registered office address, and relocating operations, are entirely different things.

Given the current state of Ireland, I really, really, really don't think you want to use the Irish tiger as a possibility for a future Scotland

Irish GDP per capita is higher than the UK. The fact that there was gross economic mismanagement over the past 15 years doesn't mean that the economy is a permanent basket case.

It's important to distinguish between relocating the plaque that says "RBS HQ" and relocating the employees - and I believe the employees have already been reassured. If there wasn't an economic reason for having thousands of employees in Scotland rather than anywhere else in the world, those jobs would already have been lost.
No matter how right you are, the UK media have picked up that "RBS will move" soundbite and run with it - so annoyingly a great deal of Scots have got "Yes = lose lots of jobs immediately" in their heads.

More on the shifty media tactics employed in this excellent piece by George Monbiot: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/sep/16/media-s...