Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sp332 4325 days ago
Where would it be used? It seems like declaring that the derivative of every prime number = 1 is entirely arbitrary.
2 comments

Yes, it is completely arbitrary. However, this arbitrary definition follows certain rules and properties and can therefore be used for certain types of mathematical reasoning.

This is why, when we talk about rings and fields and such we say "multiplication-like" or "addition-like" operators. The operators defined for the algebraic structure may not be exactly like "standard" operators, but they still follow rules and you can still do cool things with them.

Not entirely: it is the only way to do it coherently, but it is not so easy to explain.
>it is the only way to do it coherently

There are many consistent ways to define the derivative of a number.

The way we are all familiar with is to define a number as a zeroth-order polynomial.