[RogerL]

Please, no.

As soon as someone starts trying to maneuver me to take money out of my wallet, I'm gone. It's not my problem that you don't know if your product is good or not. There is no way on earth I'm signing anything, giving you a credit card number, or what have you. I'm utterly shocked that this is considered a good way to gauge interest in a product.

Even if I really am interested, so what? I have a budget, my appetite exceeds my grasp, just because your product might solve a pain point doesn't mean I will buy it. I need to consider the needs of my entire business, weigh pros and cons, and so on. If you are pulling out papers to sign after a conversation, I'm so gone.

I'm reminded of some 3rd party home alarm installers that came around to my house a few months ago. We were thinking of re-activating the alarm in the house, so we talked to them. Didn't take long for the papers to come out, etc., and it didn't take much longer for us to tell them to pound sand.

I don't give emails out (because on average the spamming becomes relentless) to landing pages, now I'm supposed to give you a CC number just so you can do marketing research?

No.

[wpietri]

Your reaction is normal for a late-majority adopter [1]. But early-stage startups are looking for the innovators and the earliest of the early adopters. When those people get to the point of saying, "OMG, I want it!" they will indeed sign contracts or pull out a credit card.

The point of asking people for money is exactly to separate the people who really are early adopters from those who are just enthusiastic.

A great example is Kickstarter. You may be unwilling to buy a product based on little more than a dream, but plenty of people are willing to take a gamble on something risky when they care enough about it. The rest of us wait until the product has come out, has been reviewed, and have friends using it.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusions_of_innovations

[philbarr]

So in which situations would you buy something?

Not trying to be snarky or anything, I know yours is a common opinion so I'm just wondering what would be a less offensive way to test the waters?

Perhaps - do the conversation, leave some contact details, give them the papers but just say, "look, no pressure, I'll leave this with you and let you think about it." Then see how many people get back to you?

[silverbax88]

Coin. (onlycoin.com)

They showed a video of what the card would do and how it would work. I actually have no idea if it will work, or does work, but it looks like it works in the video. It looks like they have something awesome. And it won't be $2000 to buy one.

They said, it should be ready within a year and you can reserve one now for 50% of the sale price (regular price $100).

So I bought one, even though I am aware that the product might never come to fruition and that my $50 might disappear. A lot of other people bought, too. I have gotten updates and I have no reason to believe I won't get my product and I'm excited that I got in on it.

But...

What did I buy, really?

I saw a guy on a video using Coin, showing how it would work, selecting different options on his card, answering all my potential questions. Man, it sure looks sweet and I can't wait to have one...

except...

did Coin really exist or did they just do a video to show how it could exist? Does it matter? I have pretty good video equipment and coding skills...and I've even hired actors for videos and done pretty well...what would stop me from hiring an actor, shooting a commercial for something like Coin, and then collecting thousands of dollars to fund the actual creation of the product?

Nothing. I just didn't think of it and didn't act on it, and they did. I'm not saying that's what they did at all, I'm just saying that could be done.

That's market validation. They sold thousands of Coin based on their idea. I have no idea if they even had working code or product, or if they were just validating whether it would sell.

[Estragon]

Maybe not such a good suggestion for a consumer-oriented product, but I've heard that this approach works well for B2B.

[pitt1980]

that's fine,

but that's evidence that you're probably not a profitable customer to chase (which again, is fine)

if you're not taking out your wallet, you're a waste of the salesmans time, the earlier they can figure this out the better