Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by udalov 4331 days ago
Not sure why they conclude that "bergamot essence may induce muscle cramps" etc based on a single case. What if the man had an allergic response of some kind and 99.99% of the population would be fine drinking so much earl grey tea?
2 comments

Because the proposed mechanism has nothing to do with histamine or immune response. Such a K+ channel blocker should hypothetically have the same effect in the vast majority of the general population.
So, if I really like Earl Grey, what would be the antidote to the K+ channel blocker?
Hypothetically if a person did experience myalgia as a direct result of drinking Earl Grey tea and their proposed mechanism is accurate, the treatment would probably involve K+ channel opener with a lower K_d (higher affinity) than the culprit bergapten, perhaps Diazoxide.
I don't think they are drawing those conclusions from this case. They appear to be pointing out that these are known reactions, based on the references.

Really, they are just reporting the surprising fact that it is possible to overdose on bergamot by drinking a large, but not unreasonably so (at least by UK standards), quantity of tea.

This of course is only one case report, so one should not assume that one needs to drink 4L of Earl Grey to induce these symptoms. I typically drink about 2L of tea per day, yet 2-3 cups of Earl Grey makes me feel nauseated. I've never had cramps or vision problems, but that's probably because I stop when I start feeling ill. This is good to know for future reference.