Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by notduncansmith 4337 days ago
Please don't hijack scroll behavior, ever. Effects that happen on scroll are one thing - but actually interfering with my ability to navigate the site via scroll is unacceptable.

As an aside, can anyone shed some light on the value generated by this behavior? Surely there's a good reason that I'm missing, because otherwise this is a scourge upon the web.

1 comments

Thanks for the feedback. We do have scroll effects, but aren't intentionally trying to hijack the scroll behaviour. Are you able to provide some more info eg, browser/os - if you could provide any screenshots to me, that would be super useful: shaun@obvious.io
Sure, it happens for me both on OS X 10.10 (Chrome) and Windows 8.1 (Chrome). It looks like you might be picking up the scroll event and then using that to scroll smoothly, rather than letting the browser actually scroll. The experience on my Macbook is that I sort of "swing" from one place to the next, rather than gliding like I usually do. On Windows (using a scroll wheel), I notice that the scroll is more of a glide, as opposed to the natural "jumpy" scrolling I experience with the scroll wheel.

It could be the case that the Macbook, being much more sensitive to scroll, is exaggerating the smoothing effect, causing the "swing".