[bmelton]

I think that the analogy works pretty well, surprisingly. I see no functional difference between changing the price in near real time as a reaction to another order on another exchange as I do "Hey, let's wait til midnight", which might equally screw the guy trying to put his order in at 11:59:59.

That said, I'm not an expert in the field, and I've just pieced this information from other posts. I have no strong opinion on the matter, but after throwaway's explanation (and all the subsequent discussion), my uninformed position agrees with his; that this article is exaggerative, and not indicative of anything being 'rigged'.

Moving fast, at least in my opinion, isn't cheating.

If they were raising the price on Ebay in response to the same customer's buy offer on Ebay, I would consider that unseemly, but not even necessarily unfair, as it only assumes that the buyer is willing to pay the newly raised price, and has approximately as much risk of losing the sale as making it.

[josephlord]

As far as I understand it a contract is made when there is an offer and an acceptance of that offer. If you are Ebay/Amazon I don't think that you can show one price and then just happen to change it as the user accepts it. The price charged should be the one offered. If the product page shows a price and user puts it in their basket and orders in within a reasonable time (5-10 minutes) the offered price should be honoured even if the price changed in the 5-10 minutes and all customers going to the product page at that point see the new price.

Note: This is not the behaviour I expect to see of share trading platforms but it is the way consumer goods sales should behave.

[harryh]

With the advent of electronic price labeling in retail stores we will soon live in a world where the price can change after you've picked up an item of the shelf and before you check out at the front of the store.

http://www.marketingmagazine.co.uk/article/1181195/real-time...

[josephlord]

I don't think that this would be legal in the UK unless on upwards changes the labels changed a reasonable[0] time before the prices. Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and probably some other laws would probably cover it.

[0] A small shop could probably do it much quicker than a large supermarket which might have to allow for people being in there for an hour.

[harryh]

Ya, I'm sure there will be tricky regulatory issues here both in the UK and elsewhere. I'm just pointing it out as I find it interesting.