[sgustard]

Agreed; the idea of hiring a musician without hearing them play would be madness. Not handing me a recording, not discussing intricacies of music theory, but actually playing live. And yet, a talented studio musician may suffer from performance anxiety in this situation. What to do?

[kilbasa]

I think the best thing is to ask them to warm up with something basic like a scale, and let them work their way up as their comfort level increases. I knew some people who were particularly pleasant and easy going, so they were able to relax people suffering from performance anxiety.

There are interviewers who treat coding interviews as a high pressure, adversarial exercise, though. On the other hand, those sorts of people are rarely a joy to work with.

[me2i81]

Performing a piece of music in a high-pressure situation is exactly a professional musician's job, so an audition is quite appropriate. Another analogy could be to ask a professional composer to play one of his pieces on piano rather than listening to a competent orchestra perform it--you're using one thing as a proxy for another. Many composers would ace it--they're great players. Some aren't, though, so you'll hire only composers who happen to be great performers. It's a dumb analogy in another way, though: you only need to know whether you can work with a composer, their work should stand on its own. I suppose if we engineering types all wrote code that went into public repositories the same might be true of us, and we wouldn't be asked to perform like trained monkeys.