[krapp]

I wouldn't call Hacker News a great product, as regards the UX and layout (which is probably the worst possible way to implement a nested list in HTML.) I would call it a great community and an acceptable product. It's basically a toy that got popular because it was attached to YCombinator, and remained popular because programmers have a higher tolerance for UX pain than mere mortals.

[marssaxman]

HN's ux is a sweet, painless relief compared to most of the web. It is unpretentious and functional. I would be disappointed if it were "improved".

[krapp]

Not every possible 'improvement' needs to slide down the slippery slope of pretentious frippery, though.

Being able to use the site more easily in mobile is would be an actual improvement. I would also argue that collapsible comments would also serve the site without degrading it. Some typographic tweaks, such as increasing the line-height, would make large text boxes easier to read. And I doubt anyone who has lost a post due to a dead link would consider Hacker News entirely painless.

[MrBra]

Thanks for saying this! Then I would say, keep this style if it impacts on the quality of HN community.