Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fleitz 4367 days ago
Said every SuperPAC ever.

What politician isn't for fixing broken government?

Who is standing up for broken government?

What congress isn't committed to fundamental reform?

2 comments

Exactly. Just the other day, Obama proclaimed that 80% of US citizens want immigration reform. When it's worded that vaguely, sure, that's true ... the vast majority want that. But "reform" means different things to different people, and very often the opposite things.

Worse, it's often mutually exclusive. In fact, "reform" to some people means ensuring we do not do the things that "reform" means to others.

Consider ... does immigration reform mean?

• keeping families together

• amnesty

• legal worker status

• in-state college tuition for non-citizens

• a fence, wall, drones, troops, sensors

• stopping Mexican troops when they cross the border

• dealing with cartels who vandalize billboards to threaten US officials (plato o plomo)

• ... etc

Many people want some of these things to happen, and want some of these things to not happen. Yet they all want "reform".

The same is true for every "reform" of "broken" government.

This is very specifically about campaign finance reform, not about "fixing broken government". Their thesis is that no fix can happen while politicians are forced to spend their time catering to very rich folks in order to keep their jobs, and this is meant to help us towards a solution.