[randomblast]

I liked the original Tower when it came out, and I paid the £50 or whatever it was since it was so much better than everything else. I don't know if it can compete with SourceTree any more though: pretty much all of its advertised new features are already present in SourceTree, which is free.

[madeofpalk]

SourceTree has a nightmare of a UI. I would much rather trade a few features for a Git client with a solid UI.

I went to just using git on the command line, and the GitHub mac app for doing commits

[nailer]

A bunch of stuff was inconsistent - I think they had three or four styles of dropdown at one point. They had a massive cleanup in 1.9 though.