[bren2013]

If you think that's the "simple truth," you either didn't read the article, or you have some piece of information you're not sharing with the rest of us.

You also know something about the "formalisms of HBC" (now redacted), and how it doesn't work with browsers that even scholars don't know about.

I think we'd all appreciate elaboration.

[tptacek]

This comment appears to be totally unresponsive to mine.

Incidentally, the "now redacted" in the parent comment refers to three bullets I had written in the grandparent comment and left for four minutes before realizing that objecting in detail to this person's blog post more or less amounted to making a full-throated defense of the Matasano post. Which, like I said, I'm not in love with either.