Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by inaworld 4388 days ago
"be the market" is the advice that comes out of portfolio theory. To say that it applies to one type of investor but not to venture investors is to basically announce that you have absolutely no understanding of portfolio theory.
2 comments
hglaser 4387 days ago
This is an odd comment. Do you think that Marc Andreessen, who manages one of the most successful portfolios of startups in the history of startups, has "absolutely no understanding of portfolio theory"?

Or do you think an alternate explanation might be more likely? Is it possible that you misunderstood something? Or is it possible that, if Marc is challenging this thesis of portfolio theory, he might be doing so from a place of great experience and be worth listening to?

link
lazyjones 4387 days ago
> Marc Andreessen, who manages one of the most successful portfolios of startups in the history of startups, has "absolutely no understanding of portfolio theory"?

He doesn't need to be above average there. Just like PG, he (mostly) invests in technology he actually comprehends, unlike some other delusionary VC from the investment banking world.

link
Punoxysm 4388 days ago
VCs deal in illiquid, information-asymmetric markets where prices are directly negotiated, capital is locked up for an extended period, and deals are large enough that investment is forced to be "lumpy".

If you could somehow invest in a startup "index", it would be great, but there really is no such thing (especially not for the VCs).

link
etjossem 4387 days ago
If you read section #1 in the article, you'll note that there are a lot of bad picks out there. To review:

  - 4,000 startups a year. 
  - 3,000 seen by a16z.
  - 200 are "fundable."
  - 15 of those generate 95% of returns.
If a single VC firm were to fund all 4,000 startups (or even a representative sample of them), they'd be out of business in a few years. A "startup index" unbiased by due diligence is a pretty bad idea from an investor perspective.

That said, if you want an example of a seed fund with a pretty broad approach, take a look at the aptly-named 500 Startups.

link
cklaus 4387 days ago
How has the 500 Startup Fund done?
link